Nelly, voiced by April Stewart, is a female fourth grade student who had made her first appearance in the Season Nine episode, "Free Willzyx" and received her first speaking role in the Season Eleven episode, "The List". She was attacked by Butters in Operation Cannot Possibly Fail when he tried to kick her in the groin, which did nothing on account of Eric Cartman's ignorance of the female body. Nelly beat up Butters giving him black eye. Another attempt was made in Operation Cannot Possibly Fail A Second Time, during which the list was taken from Nelly.
Nelly has brown hair and parts it into two pigtails. She wears a light green sweater with a picture of a daisy on it and wears dark green trousers.
Judging from Butters Stotch's injuries, Nelly is able to fight. According to Bebe Stevens, Nelly would never let the boys see the list, so it can be assumed she is trustworthy. Her ability to fight and her loyalty to the List-Making Committee may be the reason she is the keeper of the lists.
In "The List", Nelly is a member of the girls list making committee. She is in charge of holding onto and protecting lists from non-members.
- "Free Willzyx" - Seen at the Denver Aquarium with her family.
- "The List" - As one of the list keepers.
- "Tonsil Trouble" - Cheers during the fight between Kyle Broflovski and Eric Cartman.
- "Canada on Strike" - As one of the people watching Butters' video on her computer.
- "Super Fun Time " - Seen as a part of the class field trip as Emily's partner.
- "The Ring" - Watching the Jonas Brothers concert.
- "T.M.I."- Seen in the hallway, grossed out by the chart of the boys' penis sizes.
- "1%" - Seen during the school assembly.
- "Faith Hilling" - Seen exiting the school with the other students.
- "Jewpacabra" - Seen at the Easter egg hunt.
- "Butterballs" - Seen in the background in the cafeteria.
- "Raising the Bar" - Seen during the "Here Comes Fatty Doo Doo" video, where she is knocked over by Cartman's scooter.
- "Going Native" - Seen at the airport with her mom.
- "A Scause For Applause" - Seen in the background in the school hallways.
- "Let Go, Let Gov" - Seen in the school hallways talking to Tammy Nelson and Emily.
- "The Cissy" - Seen listening to Lorde's new song with Bebe and Milly in Bebe's room.
- "Stunning and Brave"- Seen in the hallway.
- "Sponsored Content"- Seen in the hallway.
- "Member Berries"- Speaks at the school assembly.
- "Skank Hunt" - Conspires with her fellow female classmates to get back at the boys for Skankhunt42's wrong doings.
- "Wieners Out" - Seen in the stands at the volleyball game.
- "Douche and a Danish" - Seen in the battle between the girls and the boys preparing to fight Butters Stotch.