Charles Kincade introduces Thad Jarvis as Kyle Broflovski's replacement for Stan Marsh's Guitar Hero team. Charles claims Thad can play the song "acoustically" on his video game controller. When Thad taps the buttons, the crowd at the cafe reacts as if they were actually hearing the song.
As Stan and Thad play the song in front of an audience of children, Kyle Broflovski arrives only to find out he was replaced. He leaves disappointed that Stan chose being famous and earning points over their friendship.