Jay Cutler is a quarterback with the Chicago Bears, formerly played for the Denver Broncos. He appeared in the episode "Guitar Queer-O" as a local celebrity at Charles Kincade's party during his time with the Broncos. Stan tells him that he kinda sucks, but his dad said he might be good some day. When asked about the parody, Cutler reportedly said, "I thought it was funny. They can make fun of me if they want to."
Jay Cutler can be seen wearing black pants and his football jersey, which is mostly blue with orange trim and his player number, six, in white on the front. He also wears black shoes and has combed brown hair.