|First||"The Spirit of Christmas - Jesus Vs. Frosty"|
Frosty appeared in "The Spirit of Christmas - Jesus Vs. Frosty". The Boys brought him to life, which resulted in Kenny and "Kenny" being killed. Frosty wreaked havoc on the Town of South Park, before being killed by baby Jesus.
Frosty had red eyes and a wide mouth with sharp teeth. He wore a top hat and was made out of snow. He also had blue tentacles.